What Is Section 329?
Section 329 of Title 11 of the United States Code (Debtor's Transactions with Attorneys) is a foundational provision of the Bankruptcy Code. It requires attorneys to disclose all compensation received or agreed to be received from a debtor in connection with the bankruptcy case. This section is a key protection against excessive attorney fees and is the basis for fee disgorgement.
Official citation: 11 U.S.C. § 329
Key Provisions of Section 329
Section 329 includes two critical provisions:
- 329(a) -- Disclosure Requirement: Any attorney representing a debtor must file a statement with the court disclosing the compensation paid or agreed to be paid for services rendered in contemplation of or in connection with the case. This includes fees paid before filing (Rule 2016(b) statement).
- 329(b) -- Fee Review Power: If the court finds the compensation exceeds the reasonable value of the services, the court may cancel any agreement and order the return of any payment to the extent excessive. The court can order disgorgement -- forcing the attorney to return fees already paid.
In practice: Section 329(b) gives the court extraordinary power over attorney fees in bankruptcy. Unlike most civil litigation where fee disputes are between attorney and client, the bankruptcy court actively polices fees as part of its duty to protect the integrity of the system.
How This Affects You
Section 329 protects debtors in several ways:
- Transparency: You have the right to know exactly what your attorney was paid, what was agreed, and by whom. These disclosures are public court filings.
- Fee reasonableness: The court (and the U.S. Trustee) reviews attorney fee disclosures for reasonableness. If your attorney charged $5,000 for a routine Chapter 7 in a district where the norm is $1,500, the court can order the excess returned.
- Disgorgement power: The court can order your attorney to return fees already paid -- not just reduce future fees. This is called disgorgement under Section 329(b).
- Third-party fee review: The U.S. Trustee regularly reviews fee disclosures and files motions to disgorge when fees appear excessive. You are not the only one watching.
Warning sign: If your attorney is reluctant to give you a clear fee agreement in writing, or if the fee seems far above what other attorneys in your area charge, that is a red flag. You can check typical fees by calling 2-3 other bankruptcy attorneys for free consultations.
Related Bankruptcy Code Sections
Section 329 works in conjunction with several other provisions of the Bankruptcy Code:
- Section 507(a)(2) -- Attorney fees as administrative expenses
- Bankruptcy Cost Guide -- What to expect for attorney fees
- Fire Your Lawyer -- Changing attorneys and fee disputes
- U.S. Trustee -- Filing complaints about attorney fees
Understanding how these sections interact is critical for anyone navigating the bankruptcy process, whether as a debtor, creditor, or attorney.
Discharge Screener · Research Platform · Exemptions by State · Keep Your Car · Keep Your House · Bankruptcy Cost · File Without a Lawyer · Rebuild Credit · Buy a House After · Buy a Car After